| 2025 |
Stephen Gorchov, Hofstra |
| 2024 |
Stephen Dombrowski, St. John's |
| 2023 |
Gregg Cohen, MBWA |
| 2022 |
Jack Jones, Fairfield |
| 2021 |
not awarded |
| 2020 |
not awarded |
| 2019 |
John Beisser, Wagner/Rutgers |
| 2018 |
Brian Beyrer, Iona |
| 2017 |
Roger Rubin, Sportswriter |
| 2016 |
Zak Ivkovic, CUNYAC |
| 2015 |
Chris Gonzales, Lehman |
| 2014 |
Ed Ingles, Sportscaster |
| 2013 |
Ken Taylor, MAAC |
| 2012 |
Joe DiBari, Fordham |
| 2011 |
Lenn Robbins, New York Post |
| 2010 |
Bruce Beck, NBC Sports |
| 2009 |
Tim Camp, New Jersey Tech |
| 2008 |
Joel Blumberg, MBWA |
| 2007 |
not awarded |
| 2006 |
Larry Torres, Madison Square Garden |
| 2005 |
Jill Skotarczak, MAAC |
| 2004 |
Jim O’Connell, Associated Press |
| 2003 |
Jeff Bernstein, NYU |
| 2002 |
Michael Graime, NJ Sports Authority |
| 2001 |
Shawn Brennan, Iona/MAAC |
| 2000 |
Tim Capstraw, Wagner/TV Commentator |
| 1999 |
Chris Fallon, NIT |
| 1998 |
Jon Halpert, Yeshiva |
| 1997 |
Helen Strus, NJ Sports Authority |
| 1996 |
John Wooding, Seton Hall |
| 1995 |
Dave Siroty, Northeast Conference |
| 1994 |
Josephine Traina, Madison Square Garden |
| 1993 |
Nick Macarchuk, Fordham |
| 1992 |
Lou Carnesecca, St. John’s |
| 1991 |
Chuck Stogel, MBWA |
| 1990 |
Jay Williams, MAAC |
| 1989 |
John Paquette, Seton Hall |
| 1988 |
Dave Magarity, Marist |
| 1987 |
P.J. Carlesimo, Seton Hall |